BLACK & BLACK CREATIVE · RETENTION & LIFECYCLE

Building Klaviyo Retention Flows After the First Order

Why most online shops stop talking to a customer the moment they buy, and what it costs them

Strategy

UX/UI Design
Development

Table of Contents

Everyone Builds the Front Door

Nearly every online shop has two pieces of email marketing set up and working: a welcome series that goes out when somebody joins the mailing list, and a reminder when somebody leaves items in their basket without paying. Those two get built first because they make money quickly and because every agency sells them.

What almost nobody builds is everything that should happen after a customer actually buys something. The shop spends money to acquire a customer, sells to them once, and then has nothing further to say.

The reason this gets missed is that it does not look like a problem. A report can tell you how much an email made; it cannot tell you about the customer who never got an email at all.

PLATFORM: 

Klaviyo

FOCUS: 

Repeat customers

CLIENTS: 

Anonymised under NDA

A premium knitwear brand

Our client since 2022. A well-built front end that stops at the first sale.

We set this brand’s email system up when it launched its online shop in 2022 and have run it ever since. That covers the email designs, the cart reminder, notices when an order ships in two parts or when a price drops, the sign-up box on the website, and three years of keeping the whole thing working as the software underneath it changes.


By 2025 the sign-up side of it was in good shape:

63.1%

OPEN RATE ON WELCOME

5.7%

CLICKED A LINK

4.8%

BOUGHT SOMETHING

45.1%

NOT BOUGHT AFTER 10 DAYS

The welcome email earns a large share of the brand's email revenue, and it does it by being selective rather than loud. One email when somebody signs up, with no entry – nobody receives it twice. Anybody who has already purchased is kept out of it. Then the system waits ten days before checking whether that person has purchased.

What we found when we reviewed the account

Every piece of automation in the account happens before somebody buys, or at the moment they buy. Nothing happens afterwards.

There was no email to a customer who had stopped ordering. Nothing to remind a customer when they were likely due to reorder. Nothing that treated a returning customer differently from a stranger. The account had become very good at turning a subscriber into a customer and had nothing to say to that customer once they were one.

What we recommended

  • An email series for the weeks after a first order, while the brand is still fresh in mind
  • Product suggestions timed to when that customer is likely to want something else
  • A separate welcome for returning customers, so a repeat buyer is not greeted as a new one
  • A real sequence for the 45% who reach the ten-day mark without buying
  • Win-back emails timed to this brand’s own reorder pattern rather than a generic three months


For a high-ticket product that people take a long time to decide on, that is where the money has been sitting untouched, and where the demand for longer nurture sequences comes in.

A haircare brand

An account we reviewed. A clever idea that had never once run.

This brand asks one question when somebody signs up: what is your hair type. The answer is saved against that person, and the system then sends them down one of three different paths, each with its own products and its own wording. It is a genuinely good idea and the brand had paid to build all of it.

The top of the sequence was healthy. 61.5% opened it, 7.9% clicked, 3.2% bought something. Then we looked at how many people had gone down each of the three paths.

The three paths - how many have ever been sent down it

Hair type A — 0 people
Hair type B — 0 people
Hair type C — 0 people

The problem

The paths were switched on and the emails were written. Subscribers were arriving, passing straight through the whole thing, and coming out the other side without ever entering any of the three. Nobody had noticed because nothing looked wrong. A path that receives nobody does not produce a bad number. It produces no number at all, and a blank space is easy to read as nothing to worry about.

What we would do about it

This is a data problem rather than a design problem, so no new emails need writing. The likely cause is small and specific. The sign-up form saves the answer in one form of words and the three paths are each looking for a slightly different one. If the form saves Curly with a capital C and the path is looking for curly in lower case, the system finds no match and sends that person down none of the three.

So the fix is to follow one real sign-up through from the form to the customer record, confirm the answer is being saved at all, and then check that what the form writes is exactly what the paths are looking for. Nothing else should be touched until people are visibly moving down the paths.

The shape both accounts share

Capability the brand has already paid for, sitting switched on and doing nothing. In one case it was never built. In the other it was built and never ran.

How we build a repeat-customer programme

The parts of Klaviyo we use, and what each one does in plain terms

Spotting a customer who is drifting away

Klaviyo keeps a record of what each customer has bought and when, and uses it to estimate when that person is likely to order next and how likely they are to stop buying altogether. Those estimates can be used to decide who gets an email and when.

The practical difference is timing. Most win-back emails go out ninety days after the last order, because ninety days is the number everybody inherits from somebody else. For a seasonal clothing brand the real gap between orders might be five months. For a shampoo it might be six weeks. The same email sent on the wrong schedule is the difference between useful and annoying. We set the timing from the brand’s own buying patterns rather than a round number, and let the system work out when each individual customer is due.

Getting them back

Emails to lapsed customers, reorder reminders, welcomes for returning customers and suggestions for a next purchase are the part most accounts are missing altogether. Done properly they are based on what the customer actually bought, when, how often, and what would sensibly come next.

The most common mistake is treating a second purchase as though it were a first. A returning customer who lands back in the standard welcome sequence gets a discount they did not need and an introduction to a brand they already know. Giving returning customers their own version, with different wording and no new-customer discount, is usually the quickest win available in any account.

Back-in-stock alerts belong here too and are badly under-used. The customer has told you which product they want and the email sends itself the moment it is available again, which makes it some of the best-performing messaging a brand can send.

Building lists from what customers do

Emails are only as good as the lists behind them, and the most reliable lists are the ones that build themselves from real behaviour rather than being updated by hand.

The most dependable version is driven by orders. We set this up on the shop side, so that when an order is placed the customer is automatically added to the right list. Where a brand needs lots of lists, by product range or material or colour, we store the destination list against each product itself, so one piece of automation reads where to send the customer off the product rather than needing a separate rule for every single line.

The other half is asking the customer directly. A sign-up form can ask one useful question, save the answer, and use it for the rest of that customer’s life with the brand. One question asked reliably and used in six places beats five questions asked and used in none.

Whichever way the data arrives, check how many people are actually moving through each path before anything else. It takes a minute and it is the difference between a clever system that runs and one that has been quietly empty since the day it launched.

Deciding who should not receive an email

Every automated email can be given rules about who is allowed into it, who should be dropped out of it part way through, and whether somebody can go through it more than once. This is the least interesting part of the job and it is the part that separates a programme that performs from one that merely exists

The best-performing welcome sequence we have worked on is also the strictest one. Nobody receives it twice, and anybody who has already bought is blocked from entering it at all. Who you keep out matters as much as what you send. Cart reminders work the opposite way. If a customer can only ever receive one, then somebody who abandons a basket three times in a year is reminded once and ignored twice. Allowing them back in after a few weeks turns a single reminder into a recurring one.

Email and text messages as one conversation

Klaviyo keeps both channels against the same customer record, with one record of what that person has agreed to receive. That means a single sequence can decide, message by message, whether this one is better as an email or a text, instead of running two separate programmes side by side. Sign-up should work the same way. One form that takes an email address and, on a phone, offers a text opt-in as well, so a single interaction builds both audiences.

Where brands run the two as separate programmes, the customer gets the same message twice in two formats and nobody can tell afterwards which one earned the sale.

Showing that it worked

Klaviyo can tell you how much money each individual email brought in, not just each sequence. That is what lets a marketing team argue for this work inside a business, because it turns a judgement call into a number.

Opens and clicks tell you that somebody paid attention. They do not tell you whether anybody bought anything. The numbers that matter are how many recipients went on to place an order and how much revenue that email is responsible for. The other number to watch, and almost nobody does, is how many people are travelling down each path. A path that nobody enters, a branch that nobody reaches, a list that never fills up: none of those produce a number that looks wrong, which is exactly why they survive for years without being noticed.

What the summary screen shows

Sequence is switched on, good open and click rates

What the paths themselves show

Nobody has been sent down any of the three paths

The six things we check first in any account

  1. How many people have actually travelled down each path, before we look at anything else
  2. Whether the gap between a customer’s orders matches when the win-back email goes out
  3. Whether a returning customer can accidentally land in the new-customer welcome
  4. Which automated emails have sent to nobody in the last ninety days
  5. Whether the automations that build the lists are switched on, not just built
  6. How much revenue each individual email brought in, not just each sequence

The argument

It now costs considerably more to win a new customer than it did a few years ago. That makes the customer a brand already has worth more than they used to be, and it makes the emails sent after a first purchase the most valuable thing most shops have not built.

Not another basket reminder. Not a bigger discount. Not more sending. A deliberate programme for the customer who has already bought once, built on information the brand is already collecting and software it is already paying for.

Keeping customers is not a switch you turn on. It is whether the right customer gets the right message at the right moment, and whether the system meant to send it is actually running.

Want to know what your account is not sending?


We review retention and lifecycle programmes in Klaviyo: what is built, what is actually running, and what has been quietly sending to nobody. You get a list of what is worth fixing first, what it would take, and what it should earn.

Contact Us

Everyone Builds the Front Door

Nearly every online shop has two pieces of email marketing set up and working: a welcome series that goes out when somebody joins the mailing list, and a reminder when somebody leaves items in their basket without paying. Those two get built first because they make money quickly and because every agency sells them.

What almost nobody builds is everything that should happen after a customer actually buys something. The shop spends money to acquire a customer, sells to them once, and then has nothing further to say.

The reason this gets missed is that it does not look like a problem. A report can tell you how much an email made; it cannot tell you about the customer who never got an email at all.

PLATFORM: 

Klaviyo

FOCUS: 

Repeat customers

CLIENTS: 

Anonymised under NDA

A premium knitwear brand

Our client since 2022. A well-built front end that stops at the first sale.

We set this brand’s email system up when it launched its online shop in 2022 and have run it ever since. That covers the email designs, the cart reminder, notices when an order ships in two parts or when a price drops, the sign-up box on the website, and three years of keeping the whole thing working as the software underneath it changes.


By 2025 the sign-up side of it was in good shape:

63.1%

OPEN RATE ON WELCOME

5.7%

CLICKED A LINK

4.8%

BOUGHT SOMETHING

45.1%

NOT BOUGHT AFTER 10 DAYS

The welcome email earns a large share of the brand's email revenue, and it does it by being selective rather than loud. One email when somebody signs up, with no entry – nobody receives it twice. Anybody who has already purchased is kept out of it. Then the system waits ten days before checking whether that person has purchased.

What we found when we reviewed the account

Every piece of automation in the account happens before somebody buys, or at the moment they buy. Nothing happens afterwards.

There was no email to a customer who had stopped ordering. Nothing to remind a customer when they were likely due to reorder. Nothing that treated a returning customer differently from a stranger. The account had become very good at turning a subscriber into a customer and had nothing to say to that customer once they were one.

What we recommended

  • An email series for the weeks after a first order, while the brand is still fresh in mind
  • Product suggestions timed to when that customer is likely to want something else
  • A separate welcome for returning customers, so a repeat buyer is not greeted as a new one
  • A real sequence for the 45% who reach the ten-day mark without buying
  • Win-back emails timed to this brand’s own reorder pattern rather than a generic three months


For a high-ticket product that people take a long time to decide on, that is where the money has been sitting untouched, and where the demand for longer nurture sequences comes in.

A haircare brand

An account we reviewed. A clever idea that had never once run.

This brand asks one question when somebody signs up: what is your hair type. The answer is saved against that person, and the system then sends them down one of three different paths, each with its own products and its own wording. It is a genuinely good idea and the brand had paid to build all of it.

The top of the sequence was healthy. 61.5% opened it, 7.9% clicked, 3.2% bought something. Then we looked at how many people had gone down each of the three paths.

The three paths - how many have ever been sent down it

Hair type A — 0 people
Hair type B — 0 people
Hair type C — 0 people

The problem

The paths were switched on and the emails were written. Subscribers were arriving, passing straight through the whole thing, and coming out the other side without ever entering any of the three. Nobody had noticed because nothing looked wrong. A path that receives nobody does not produce a bad number. It produces no number at all, and a blank space is easy to read as nothing to worry about.

What we would do about it

This is a data problem rather than a design problem, so no new emails need writing. The likely cause is small and specific. The sign-up form saves the answer in one form of words and the three paths are each looking for a slightly different one. If the form saves Curly with a capital C and the path is looking for curly in lower case, the system finds no match and sends that person down none of the three.

So the fix is to follow one real sign-up through from the form to the customer record, confirm the answer is being saved at all, and then check that what the form writes is exactly what the paths are looking for. Nothing else should be touched until people are visibly moving down the paths.

The shape both accounts share

Capability the brand has already paid for, sitting switched on and doing nothing. In one case it was never built. In the other it was built and never ran.

How we build a repeat-customer programme

The parts of Klaviyo we use, and what each one does in plain terms

Spotting a customer who is drifting away

Klaviyo keeps a record of what each customer has bought and when, and uses it to estimate when that person is likely to order next and how likely they are to stop buying altogether. Those estimates can be used to decide who gets an email and when.

The practical difference is timing. Most win-back emails go out ninety days after the last order, because ninety days is the number everybody inherits from somebody else. For a seasonal clothing brand the real gap between orders might be five months. For a shampoo it might be six weeks. The same email sent on the wrong schedule is the difference between useful and annoying. We set the timing from the brand’s own buying patterns rather than a round number, and let the system work out when each individual customer is due.

Getting them back

Emails to lapsed customers, reorder reminders, welcomes for returning customers and suggestions for a next purchase are the part most accounts are missing altogether. Done properly they are based on what the customer actually bought, when, how often, and what would sensibly come next.

The most common mistake is treating a second purchase as though it were a first. A returning customer who lands back in the standard welcome sequence gets a discount they did not need and an introduction to a brand they already know. Giving returning customers their own version, with different wording and no new-customer discount, is usually the quickest win available in any account.

Back-in-stock alerts belong here too and are badly under-used. The customer has told you which product they want and the email sends itself the moment it is available again, which makes it some of the best-performing messaging a brand can send.

Building lists from what customers do

Emails are only as good as the lists behind them, and the most reliable lists are the ones that build themselves from real behaviour rather than being updated by hand.

The most dependable version is driven by orders. We set this up on the shop side, so that when an order is placed the customer is automatically added to the right list. Where a brand needs lots of lists, by product range or material or colour, we store the destination list against each product itself, so one piece of automation reads where to send the customer off the product rather than needing a separate rule for every single line.

The other half is asking the customer directly. A sign-up form can ask one useful question, save the answer, and use it for the rest of that customer’s life with the brand. One question asked reliably and used in six places beats five questions asked and used in none.

Whichever way the data arrives, check how many people are actually moving through each path before anything else. It takes a minute and it is the difference between a clever system that runs and one that has been quietly empty since the day it launched.

Deciding who should not receive an email

Every automated email can be given rules about who is allowed into it, who should be dropped out of it part way through, and whether somebody can go through it more than once. This is the least interesting part of the job and it is the part that separates a programme that performs from one that merely exists

The best-performing welcome sequence we have worked on is also the strictest one. Nobody receives it twice, and anybody who has already bought is blocked from entering it at all. Who you keep out matters as much as what you send. Cart reminders work the opposite way. If a customer can only ever receive one, then somebody who abandons a basket three times in a year is reminded once and ignored twice. Allowing them back in after a few weeks turns a single reminder into a recurring one.

Email and text messages as one conversation

Klaviyo keeps both channels against the same customer record, with one record of what that person has agreed to receive. That means a single sequence can decide, message by message, whether this one is better as an email or a text, instead of running two separate programmes side by side. Sign-up should work the same way. One form that takes an email address and, on a phone, offers a text opt-in as well, so a single interaction builds both audiences.

Where brands run the two as separate programmes, the customer gets the same message twice in two formats and nobody can tell afterwards which one earned the sale.

Showing that it worked

Klaviyo can tell you how much money each individual email brought in, not just each sequence. That is what lets a marketing team argue for this work inside a business, because it turns a judgement call into a number.

Opens and clicks tell you that somebody paid attention. They do not tell you whether anybody bought anything. The numbers that matter are how many recipients went on to place an order and how much revenue that email is responsible for. The other number to watch, and almost nobody does, is how many people are travelling down each path. A path that nobody enters, a branch that nobody reaches, a list that never fills up: none of those produce a number that looks wrong, which is exactly why they survive for years without being noticed.

What the summary screen shows

Sequence is switched on, good open and click rates

What the paths themselves show

Nobody has been sent down any of the three paths

The six things we check first in any account

  1. How many people have actually travelled down each path, before we look at anything else
  2. Whether the gap between a customer’s orders matches when the win-back email goes out
  3. Whether a returning customer can accidentally land in the new-customer welcome
  4. Which automated emails have sent to nobody in the last ninety days
  5. Whether the automations that build the lists are switched on, not just built
  6. How much revenue each individual email brought in, not just each sequence

The argument

It now costs considerably more to win a new customer than it did a few years ago. That makes the customer a brand already has worth more than they used to be, and it makes the emails sent after a first purchase the most valuable thing most shops have not built.

Not another basket reminder. Not a bigger discount. Not more sending. A deliberate programme for the customer who has already bought once, built on information the brand is already collecting and software it is already paying for.

Keeping customers is not a switch you turn on. It is whether the right customer gets the right message at the right moment, and whether the system meant to send it is actually running.

Want to know what your account is not sending?


We review retention and lifecycle programmes in Klaviyo: what is built, what is actually running, and what has been quietly sending to nobody. You get a list of what is worth fixing first, what it would take, and what it should earn.

Contact Us